The moteus line of brushless motor controllers currently require a CAN-FD host to send commands in order to actually execute a motion profile. moteus has long provided a python library that can be used on desktop operating systems to send commands and parse responses, and recently added a C++ one as well. Next up, and described in this post, is a library for Arduino which provides the ability to command and monitor brushless motors using moteus motor controllers.
I’m excited to announce a big price drop for the moteus-r4.11 controller for both single units and in volume!
| Quantity | Old | New |
|---|---|---|
| 1-10 | $104 | $79 |
| 10-99 | $99 | $75 |
| 100-499 | $94 | $71 |
We’ve been scaling up production, which enables these reductions of about 25% across the board. moteus-r4 is now by far the most cost effective motor driver with integrated encoder in its class. Here’s a quick comparison with similar products:
| ODRIVE S1 | Tinymover R5.2 | moteus-r4.11 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 12-50.5V | 12-38V | 10-44V |
| Continuous phase current | 40A | Not specified | 22A |
| Peak current | 80A | 40A | 100A |
| Dimensions | 66mm x 50mm | 40mm x 36mm | 53mm x 46mm |
| Open source | Proprietary FW and HW | GPL FW, Proprietary HW | Apache 2.0 FW and HW |
| Price | $149 | $108 | $79 |
I personally am looking forward to all the new projects that these lower prices enable! Check it out below or join the mjbots Discord to chat and get some ideas for how you can use a moteus-r4.
I’ve been looking for a new motor control project to tackle that is both interesting, and a bit more unique than another Ascento clone. Looking around, I was surprised at the current paucity of robots capable of more advanced juggling feats. There are quite a few that can manage 3 balls, and nearly none I’ve found that can manage more, with the exception of Nathan Peterson’s inclined ball roller. I figure that I have access to lots of factory second moteus controllers, which are capable of quite demanding control applications, so I should be able to put something together.
The perils of technical videos is that they can become out of date pretty quickly. For the moteus getting started guide, it has amazingly held up pretty well, but enough has changed since 2021 that it is time for a new one. Now we can use acceleration and velocity limited commands instead of the deprecated stop position and get nicer 4k b-roll for all the intermissions. Everything in the old video, and in this new one, is applicable to both the moteus-r4.11 and the moteus-n1.
Back last year, I walked through bisecting and debugging an annoying problem that caused the STM32G4 ADC on the moteus controller to exhibit higher than expected noise in result largely to either the exact placement in flash of the initialization code, or to the exact timing of the initialization. While the immediate glaring sharp edge was removed, the resulting performance still was confusing to me, and looked like it was not yet optimal. Further, a moderate percentage (2% or so), of production boards failed end-of-line tests related to the current sense noise in ways that were hard to fix by swapping components. Because of this, I wanted to dive in and investigate further. This is that process.
I don’t normally post about moteus firmware releases, but there have been many in the last few months that fix some long standing bugs and regressions. First, the current release as of this post is:
With that out of the way, here some of the fixes:
It is embarrassing how long this issue has been outstanding, but ever since the flexible I/O system was introduced, there has been an issue where if the gear reduction was configured to a value other than 1, then the output position would drift from the source encoder over time. If control was not active, you would see the position drift, and if control was active, then moteus would report the correct position, but the actual position would drift.
moteus r4.11 has two external connectors, the ABS connector (AUX2) and the ENC/AUX1 connector. The ABS connector was designed initially just to have 2 I2C pins. The ENC connector just has the random pins that were used for the onboard encoder SPI plus one more. Thus the range of external accessories that can be connected is somewhat haphazard and not necessarily all that useful.
When working on a more ground up revision of the controller, I wanted to improve that situation to expose more connectivity options on still a relatively limited connector set. The idea was to use 2 connectors, one which has 5 I/O pins and the other with 4 I/O pins. The onboard encoder SPI would still be accessible on the larger connector to use for at least one external SPI encoder, but how much other functionality could be crammed into the remaining pins? To start, lets see what possible options there are in the current firmware and supported by the STM32G4 microcontroller that moteus uses:
With the release of more flexible I/O support, the moteus controller auxiliary port can be used to monitor encoders using an onboard UART. Now, with firmware release 2023-02-01, those UART pins can be used as an arbitrary logic level serial port controlled by the application! Let’s see how to use it below.
First, you will need to look at the pin configuration table to find pins that support UART functionality, and configure them as UART in the “aux?.pins” configuration tree. Next, “aux?.uart.mode” should be set to “kTunnel”, along with the desired baud rate. That’s it on the configuration front.
Partly to celebrate moteus controllers being back in stock and partly because a lot of important work has backed up, we’ve just released a new firmware version for moteus (2023-02-01) that has a little bit of something for everyone. Future posts will examine some of these features in more detail, but for now you just get the bullet list:
Support sending and receiving arbitrary data from a UART configured on either of the auxiliary ports
Here’s a not-so-brief story about troubleshooting a problem that was at times vexing, impossible, incredibly challenging, frustrating, and all around just a terrible time with the bare-metal STM32G4 firmware for the moteus brushless motor controller.
First, some things for context:
moteus has a variety of testing done on every firmware release. There are unit tests that run with pieces of the firmware compiled to run in a host environment. There is a hardware-in-the-loop dynamometer test fixture that is used to run a separate battery of tests. There is also an end-of-line test fixture that is used to run tests on every board and some other firmware level performance tests.
