I’ve been exploring how to add low cost off-axis encoder support into moteus, see part 1, and part 2. In this part, I’ll look at a magnet and how to get it installed on the test motor.

To start, this method of operation will require a diametrically magnetized ring magnet, i.e. one where the axis of magnetization is through the diameter rather than through its depth.

That is not a terribly common magnet configuration, but there are some vendors. For this experiment, I used a 32mm OD ring magnet from RLS that is intended for use with their Orbis line of encoders, part number BM220C320A1ABA00. The motor I am using for this test is a T-Motor GL80, which has a hollow shaft. To mate the magnet to the motor, I 3d printed a fixture (purple) which slipped over the bearing surfaces of the GL80 (pink), and captured the magnet (red).

In the previous post, I outlined a possible path to low cost off-axis encoders to be used with the moteus line of brushless controllers. The first step I took was to try and build a minimally sized breakout board that could be used with the MA732/MA702/MA600 line of hall effect angle sensors. You can get these off the shelf, for instance from tinymovr, but I wanted to see if I could make something a bit more compact, and that had the chip close to a board edge so that it could be used for off axis applications.

The moteus line of brushless controllers all have an integrated “on-axis” magnetic encoder. These encoders are designed to allow moteus to sense the position of a motor’s shaft directly, assuming that an appropriate diametrically magnetized sense magnet is attached to the rotating shaft and the moteus is mounted so that its sensor is positioned over the magnet.

This works great for many applications, but what about hollow shaft motors? moteus supports a few encoder types that will work for off axis encoders, most notably is the AksIM-2. This is a high performance off-axis encoder that gives great performance and is manufactured in configurations for a variety of hollow shaft diameters. However, it does have downsides. First, it comes with a commensurate price tag. In single quantities, the AksIM-2 and magnetic code disc are more expensive than an entire moteus brushless motor controller. Second, only the moteus-n1 has the necessary RS422 transceiver integrated into it. All other moteus boards need an external RS422 transceiver.

As of release 2023-09-26, moteus r4 and moteus-n1 now both support the MA732 as an external SPI encoder. The magnetic sensing performance of the MA732 is normally a bit worse than the AS5047P that is used as the onboard encoder with moteus, but it has two possible advantages.

The first, is that it is much smaller, using a 3mm x 3mm QFN package. The second is that it supports off-axis applications. You will need to read the datasheet, and set the 'aux?.spi.bct' configuration parameter correctly, but this can enable operation in interesting geometries, like a ring magnet with a hollow shaft, or where the coaxial placement is otherwise not feasible.

The moteus controller, uses an absolute magnetic encoder to sense the position of the rotor and thus be capable of field oriented control FOC of brushless motors. To date, all the iterations of the controller have used the AS5047P encoder from ams. This is relatively common, works fine over SPI and hasn’t caused any problems. While investigating some other issues, I decided to take a stab at trying some alternate encoders. First, I tried the AS5047U, which is the same basic encoder, but incorporates a digital filter. I also tried the MA732, from Monolithic Power, which uses a different operating principle and also includes a digital filter. The plus side of the MA732 is that it reports full 16 bit values, even if not all of them provide a lot of value.